has any one cc'd the combustion chambers?
the difference between the 2 pistons isnt huge, but its definitly noticable...
plenty of ppl have put black heads on silver bottoms.
i havnt heard of any issues.... and i havnt had the chance to compare them side by side except in pics
if i was you id source another blacktop piston, and rebuild using:
silvertop block, crank and rods, for all the rest use the blacktop bits.
the weaskest link in the blacktops is as youv found, is the rods.
from what youv got that sounds like the cheapest and easiest option.
i did a price check on blacktops today..... they are not cheap!