I would buy the Windom, 1800 bucks is cheap as shit. Personally i would pay the little extra per week in fuel to drive a real car as opposed to a corolla
Our good family friends have the Lexus version (ES300) which has some ridiculous mileage on it (close to 300000) and it still looks showroom new, theres no paint fade at all, the leather doesnt crack, and u can barely hear the engine run. It is NOT slow either. Theyre just built to a much better standard than mass produced small cars so if i was looking for a relaible daily i would definately take one of them over most other Toyotas..